Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Shohl's avatar

Nice job explaining the temperaments to a general audience. JSB deliberately includes all seven white keys and all five black keys -- all twelve notes on any clavier/keyboard -- so the performer can check the temperament’s setting as they play through the piece. This survey of all available pitches is also why the texture --purely open chords, no melody, no heavy counterpoint -- is SO simple and transparent: so that the listener can zero in on the “beating” shimmering effect created by well-temperament’s slight dissonances.

I didn’t know about Evita or Don’t Cry for Me, thanks. Some people may also know of the opera composer Gounod’s setting of the Ave Maria, based on the Bach

Expand full comment
Dan's avatar

Much like yourself Josh I’ve been in a dark place recently and I forget to revel in music. Thank you so much for this. I have two hours of Bach to listen to on a hike through the woods on this beautiful sunny evening.

Expand full comment
14 more comments...

No posts